Washington’s Trans Sports Ban Seemed Poised for a Lawsuit. It’s Getting One.

Posted

If Initiative 638, which Washington voters passed with 56 percent of the vote, goes into effect in December, it will ban trans girls from playing on youth sports teams at public schools—and require all girl student-athletes to prove their biological sex. That’s only if it survives the lawsuit filed by the ACLU of Washington, gender equality advocacy group Legal Voice, and the statewide teacher’s union Washington Education Association.

Three days after the initiative results were certified, the groups filed a suit seeking emergency relief to keep it from going into effect on December 3. According to the lawsuit, the ballot measure—which only applies to girls’ sports and trans athletes—would violate multiple provisions of the state constitution. By focusing only on girls’ sports, advocates argue, it would violate the state’s Equal Rights Amendment, and imposing sex verification requirements would violate student privacy, which is also protected under the state constitution.

If I-638 does go into effect, it would put an abrupt end to Washington’s nearly 20-year history of trans-inclusive school sports.

“This new requirement is in direct conflict with the state’s paramount duty to educate our children without discrimination,” said Janie White, president of the Washington Education Association (WEA), which represents 90,000 educators in the state and signed onto the lawsuit, in a news release. “Washington educators are committed to fair and welcoming schools where all students can thrive.”

While the measure focuses on youth sports, Legal Voice policy director Alizeh Bhojani said the threat reflects a much larger ongoing attack on transgender people. “This is definitely part of a broader pattern to push trans people out of public life,” she said, citing bathroom bills and ongoing conservative efforts to constrain access to gender-affirming care.

Opposition to the measure has picked up steam since its passage: Last week, the Seattle Public Schools board of directors voted in support of the district legally challenging the law, something Mayor Katie Wilson cosigned on social media, writing, “I support the Board’s decision and its commitment to creating inclusive learning environments where every student has the opportunity to reach their full potential.”

Last Friday, Attorney General Nick Brown announced that to avoid a conflict of interest, he was bringing in an outside law firm to defend the measure in court. (In true Seattle-is-a-small-town fashion, Pacifica Law Group, the firm taking on the case, also happens to employ former Mayor Jenny Durkan.) The office of the attorney general has advocated on behalf of transgender Washingtonians, and, according to Brown, “We will not and cannot abandon that work.”

Defending the measure may be a challenge given its vague language around enforcement, and the complications it raises in light of the state’s privacy and equal rights policies as well as existing protections for transgender Washingtonians. According to the original language of the initiative, the sex verification requirement for girls who want to play school sports would come from “leveraging the existing physical examination process to verify biological sex.”

But as it’s currently written, the standard sports physical form used statewide under the purview of the Washington Interscholastic Activities Association (WIAA) does not address biological sex at all, just physical attributes and conditions that might make playing sports unsafe for some kids. Noting a cardiovascular or musculoskeletal condition, for example, is a matter of a student’s physical health and safety. Examining and reporting their biological sex is not. The initiative makes no effort to address this mismatch. Another step would need to be introduced into the sports physical process to address biological sex. The ballot measure doesn’t clarify how this would happen, or how it would need to be implemented for students who’ve already obtained a sports physical for the school year.

In fact, the initiative’s Tim Eyman-esque proponent, Brian Heywood, has pushed the idea that the sports physical is an obvious method of determining biological sex, despite its total absence from the form. Advocates fighting the law say this lack of clarity is a huge problem and that it’s predicated on ideas about trans athletes that just aren’t borne out by science.

While anti-trans activists have argued that transgender athletes have an unfair advantage in girls’ sports, the reality doesn’t square with those talking points.

According to a scientific literature review published in Frontiers of Sport and Active Living, there is little data to back this up: “The disproportionate focus on the relatively small portion of the population who are trans seems based on the belief that cis men, who cannot succeed in sports among other cis men, would choose to misidentify as trans women to gain an advantage in sports against cis women,” writes author DJ Oberlin. “However, there are no legitimate cases of this occurring. An individual’s sex does not determine their success or failure at any athletic event despite the high level of competition.”

According to Aidan Key, who advocated for Washington’s trans-inclusive school sports policy when it was first introduced in 2007, educators and rule-making organizations have noted “no distinguishable difference” in athletic performance between trans and cis student athletes. “So this idea that trans girls are going to be dominating girls’ sports is not happening,” he says.

Advocates say this crusade for “fairness” would threaten all girls who play sports and violate the state’s Equal Rights Amendments, because the law’s sex verification would impose a new administrative burden on certain, but not all students and their families—one that isn’t medically necessary, isn’t adequately explained in the language of the initiative, and may not even be covered by insurance. “This is going to be very chaotic for school districts to implement, because we have no clue how they’re going to do that,” said the ACLU’s Adrien Leavitt.

And it’s unclear how girls will have to prove their sex. 

“Will that require new medical appointments?” said Legal Voice’s Bhojani. “If it’s not medically necessary, will that be covered by insurance? If a family opts for hormone or genetic testing, that’s going to be even more costly and inconvenient and a delay.”

On Tuesday, the Seattle Times reported that WIAA would be updating its policies to align with I-638 by the measure’s implementation date, December 3. Girls participating in winter sports would need to confirm their biological sex by that date. Bhojani said she hoped an injunction blocking the measure would be granted before then.

The post Washington’s Trans Sports Ban Seemed Poised for a Lawsuit. It’s Getting One. appeared first on The Stranger.

News, brian heywood, LGBTQ, sports, trans sports ban