
David Fincher and Quentin Tarantino may have started their Hollywood careers around the same time and may work in similar genres, but they have wildly different sensibilities. Amid his penchant for brutal onscreen violence, Tarantino is a softie who has affection for his characters: His villains are clever and quick-witted, regardless of whether they are deadly assassins or psychotic Nazis, the type with whom you might almost want to share a conversation. In stark contrast from his icy thrillers, Fincher is a misanthrope down to his intellectual core: He feels disdain for his characters, including his heroes, so what makes them compelling is the deadpan irony that runs through his work (the best way to understand 2014’s Gone Girl, for example, is as Fincher’s version of a romantic comedy).
These two collaborating should be like oil and water, but in The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth—directed by Fincher and written by Tarantino—they counterintuitively complement each other. In this sequel to 2019’s Once Upon a Time … in Hollywood, the pair have a period crime film that lacks sentimentality—at times, it can be breathtakingly brutal—yet manages to preserve some humanity so you still care about what befalls its complex, agreeably flawed characters. If there is a shaggy-dog quality here, an unhurried need to finish its crisscrossing plot threads, at least the filmmakers resolve them with a brusque finality that fits nicely in the late mid-1970s milieu when it unfolds.

It has been eight years since Cliff Booth (Brad Pitt), a charismatic stuntman with a dark side, subdued members of the Manson Family. Now he can’t get reliable stunt work, so now he takes odd jobs as a projectionist, bartender, whatever. When he does get showbiz work, it’s as a “fixer” who does unseemly favors for a fee: In the opening sequence, Cliff negotiates on behalf of a big shot director who had his jewelry and his Oscar stolen from a couple thugs who do not realize how dangerous Cliff can be. Not only did Cliff kill some home invaders, he’s known throughout Los Angeles as the guy who once beat up Bruce Lee, and who murdered his wife before that. Pitt’s performance is what makes Cliff so compelling: He leans on his good looks and natural charisma, making Cliff the kind of hunk who has a preternatural ability to put anyone at ease. This quality gets him out of sticky situations, and into serious trouble.
The misadventures take a little time to develop. Cliff gets a call from Karen Crosby (Elizabeth Debicki), an agent for the TV star Charlie Peters (Scott Caan), who needs Cliff for nefarious reasons. Charlie got into it with some Filipino gangsters (Matt Groove and JB Tadena), who are in town to collect a debt the actor does not want to pay. But before Cliff cleans up this mess, he spends several days seducing Karen, and his strategy is to be transparent about his attraction to her. Does he want to hook up? Not exactly. He wants her to slap him in the face, another detail that suggests Cliff is a junkie for any kind of intense sensation, including pain. Debicki and Pitt may have a significant age gap—he is nearly 30 years her senior—but the pair has such natural chemistry that you find yourself rooting for them as a couple. The scenes with just the two of them are a highlight, and recall the parts in Pulp Fiction between John Travolta and Uma Thurman where a growing, unspoken bond beefs up all the sexual tension.
At first, Fincher’s contribution is less obvious. The opening sequence involves a movie-within-a-movie, a blaxploitation scene that depicts just how far the movie industry has changed from the sunny good times of the preceding decade. This kind of self-referential material is common to Tarantino; you can feel Fincher’s calculating, dispassionate eye later in a home invasion scene with the two brothers. They are ruthless and Fincher shoots in a way that underlines the threat they represent. You can’t imagine Tarantino taking such a cold-blooded approach, and when the brothers have their inevitable standoff with Cliff, there is more suspense than Tarantino can usually muster. Even relatively low-stakes scenes, like Cliff in a demolition derby or a tennis match, all have a menacing air to them.

But the final showdown is classic Tarantino, a buildup of words and forced camaraderie with a deadly subtext. Despite the terrific action that serves as payoff for the suspense, some may find the ending of The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth unsatisfying, to the point where it might be divisive or controversial. For Tarantino and Fincher, genre stylists at the height of their powers, that is part of the point. Fans of 1970s genre movies will recognize its perfunctory nature: This ending is uncompromising, without any fat, built out of an understanding that who survives is more important than who lives happily ever after.
Maybe you recall 1975’s French Connection II, another movie where a great actor reprises his Oscar-winning antihero character in a much more sinister, darker sequel. Like Cliff, the hero of French Connection II believes nothing better than vanquishing his enemy because it means preserving his strict, archaic code as its own reward. If the 1970s were a period of pervasive cynicism, then Fincher and Tarantino make shrewd choices in their collaboration to reflect those values. Sometimes a solid kiss-off line is all you get, and in this one, they indulge Cliff just a little bit by letting him have a doozy.
The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth (R, 140 mins.) opens in area theaters on Nov. 25.