The Decline and Importance of Election Concessions

Posted
Michigan Republican Senate candidate Mike Rogers speaks at an election night event in Detroit. His victorious Democratic opponent, Abdul El-Sayed, says Rogers never called him to concede or congratulate.

A funny thing happened in my home state of Kentucky on election night: Two candidates for state legislature ended a hard-fought campaign with genuine grace. This quality has seemed all but lost in American politics.

Republican Killion Timoney served two terms in the Kentucky House but lost to Democrat Adam Moore in 2024. The two faced off again in 2026. Outside money infiltrated the race, with the Commonwealth Conservative Coalition spending $40,000 on attack ads against Moore, calling him “extreme.” Timoney posted an image on Facebook with an “AI content” tag that compared the two candidates, saying “results over rhetoric.” Moore responded with a comment that read, “Careful when using AI, it will invent new facts like a two-term representative serving six sessions while conveniently leaving out tens of millions of dollars in critical funding. Blatant lies, maybe that’s why Killion Timoney declined two debates and two public forums with me.”

On election night, Moore won the hotly contested district by a vote of 11,185 to 9,455, or a margin of 1,730. That evening, Timoney posted on Facebook, “Well … we came up short. I really felt so much positive energy. I felt like we were making progress. Sadly, it was not enough to win. To say I’m heartbroken is an understatement. I loved serving in the legislature, and I felt like I was able to contribute to the betterment of the Commonwealth. I just got off the phone with my opponent, [Adam] Moore, after congratulating him on such a hard-fought battle. I lost fair and square. No excuses. I hope he takes a well-needed break to celebrate.”

The next morning, Moore posted his own message on Facebook: “I want to give a quick shout-out to my opponent, Killion Timoney, for giving me a call last night. Killion, thank you for offering to help me better serve our district by being someone I can reach out to regarding public education policy, something I know is a real passion of yours. To those who voted for me or against me, I want to reiterate that there is so much more that unites us as Americans than divides us. Let’s continue the work of loving our neighbor and helping one another.”

Timoney then commented on that post: “Thank you, Adam. Continue to work hard for the 45th [District]. You’ve definitely earned this opportunity. Congratulations. Congratulations to [your wife and child]. They earned a shout-out too!”

Another Democratic state legislator who won re-election then wrote, “Thank you, Killion Timoney. You’re the only state legislative candidate that I’ve heard of calling their opponent, and that speaks volumes.”

There are similar examples from across the country. In today’s environment, they deserve praise.

It’s how candidates should always behave. Win or lose, political candidates have identified themselves as leaders in the community. People will take their cues from how they act and whether they uphold the ideals of democracy. In 2020, Donald Trump told his supporters that the election was fraudulent, and thousands of them stormed the U.S. Capitol to protest the result. In 2026, the Democrats’ margin of victory was overwhelming in most places, earning the refrain “too big to rig.”

But close or not, losing candidates have a responsibility to democracy to tell their supporters that they accept the results and the legitimacy of the electoral process. This should be expected practice, from the president down to candidates for local office.

However, as The New York Times reported last week, political candidates conceding after they lose is no longer common.

In the hotly contested election in Michigan for U.S. Senator, Republican Mike Rogers never called his opponent, Democrat Abdul El-Sayed, to concede. Rogers instead simply thanked his supporters during his speech. In Florida, Democratic congressional candidate Nicole Locklin, down by just over 1,000 votes, did not concede the race to incumbent Republican U.S. Representative Mario Díaz-Balart, even though the Associated Press has called the race. Instead, she filed a lawsuit demanding the release of voting records she claims showed her initially ahead on election night.

Republican Roy Moore apparently never conceded the 2018 U.S. Senate election in Alabama to Democrat Doug Jones. And, of course, Donald Trump still has not conceded the 2020 election, continuing to claim that he won. He has also begun to question the results of the 2026 midterms, posting a conspiracy theory on Truth Social about “voting dumps.”

Candidates are not required to issue a formal concession. A concession has no legal significance beyond signaling that the losing candidate won’t fight the outcome. Election officials will certify the results regardless of a concession. Of course, if there are legitimate questions about the vote-casting or counting process, candidates can turn to the courts, but that should be the exception, not the norm. Recounts and post-election litigation rarely change vote totals enough to alter the results. And even then, candidates should gracefully concede once it is clear they have lost.

A concession is a time-honored tradition and a key part of democracy: Losers should recognize the legitimacy of the results and hope to persuade more voters to their cause in a future election. As The New York Times wrote last week, “failing to concede defeat is more frequent than ever, the latest norm of polite politics to become a casualty of a less civil age.”

Given that concession seems out of vogue during an era when democracy is under attack, it is especially worthwhile to encourage candidates to concede when they have lost, signaling to their supporters that they, too, should accept the result. A concession helps instill the democratic norm that voters have primacy.

Moreover, a concession should go beyond a simple statement that the candidate understands the results. It should explicitly recognize the legitimacy of the winning candidate’s entitlement to office. It should also try to heal any wounds inflicted during a tough campaign—just as Timoney did in Kentucky.

That practice is what makes democracy strong and helps it endure. It’s time to make concessions great again.


The post The Decline and Importance of Election Concessions appeared first on Washington Monthly.

Featured, Main, Politics, Abdul el-Sayed, Adam Monroe, Donald Trump, Doug Jones, kentucky, Killion Timoney, Mario Diaz-Balart, Mike Rogers, Nicole Locklin, Roy Moore