Heads or tails? How Minnesota cities break ties in elections

Posted
voting booth

A coin flip will decide if the Vikings kick off or receive to start Sunday’s game. On rare occasions, this same method can be used to determine elections.

A Pine Island City Council race was one of at least three Minnesota elections to end in dead heats this fall, necessitating a tiebreaker as set forth in state law.

But the state statute isn’t picky about how to break ties; it simply says a canvassing board “shall determine the tie by lot.”

In theory, that means any random game of chance could be used to settle a deadlocked contest. Cities tend to keep it simple, though, as evidenced by the following ways they broke ties this year. 

Two sides of the coin

Two candidates for Pine Island City Council received 711 votes on Election Day and only one of them could claim the last of two open seats: Delana Weis or Dominick Pahl.

A coin flip decided their fates. Weis, the incumbent, called heads, leaving tails for Pahl. 

Heads landed up, according to the Rochester Post Bulletin. Weis will return to the council, where she has voted with other council members in support of the city’s hyperscale data center project. 

Landing on tails wouldn’t have sent a data center opponent to the council, though. Pahl also expressed support for it during his campaign. 

While Pine Island chose a coin flip to break a tie, one state requires it. Idaho’s secretary of state summons tied candidates in state or district races for a flip of a coin within two days of the state’s canvass.  

Most states, 28, mirror Minnesota’s drawing of lots or similar such methods for settling tied state House or Senate seats, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures. In 12 states, ties result in new elections.

Then we have New Jersey and New York, where gaps in legislation seem to invite chaos. They have nothing on the books to break ties.

Drawing names

The most used method for breaking ties this year? Drawing names at random. 

Spring Lake Park went this route, which wasn’t even the most interesting development in the Twin Cities suburb’s mayoral contest.

Incumbent Bob Nelson and Halyn Roth were initially tied at 1,401 votes. So, the city administrator folded pieces of paper with their names on it and placed them in identical looking film canisters. A city council member pulled a canister from a tote bag and, voila, Nelson’s name was drawn.

That wasn’t the end of it, though. Roth requested a recount, successfully challenged a ballot and has since been declared the winner by one vote. 

The race may yet be in for another turn. Nelson has a window to challenge the result in Anoka County District Court. 

Instead of Spring Lake Park’s tote bag, St. Francis used a tall bowl for drawing names to settle a mayoral primary in August. Aaron Hill and Sarah Udvig tied in the race to face incumbent Mayor Mark Vogel. 

Angie Bray Johnson, a city council member in neighboring Oak Grove, did the honors of pulling a piece of paper from the bowl. “There were definitely nerves and emotions in everybody,” she said. “I was like. ‘Oh my gosh, I’m doing this.’”

She pulled out the first paper she felt, which had Hill’s name on it. As disappointed as Johnson was for her friend, Udvig, she said that’s the “luck of the draw.” 

Hill ended up losing to Vogel in the general election.

Tiebreakers of yore

Carlton County had two tied elections in 2024, according to MPR.

Kettle River used a deck of cards to break a deadlock between two council candidates who received 33 votes. Whoever drew the highest card would win.

Would an ace be considered high or low? City officials thought of that, opting to only shuffle and use cards two through nine. 

Patricia Lund’s seven bested Laura Simi’s five.

Wrenshall, meanwhile, drew a name out of a hat. Jeff Bloom unseated incumbent mayor Gary Butala by that method. 

A hat also broke a tie in the closest legislative race in Minnesota history, according to the Minnesota Legislative Reference Library. C.A. Johnson Sr., an independent nicknamed “Little Gus,” and Donald Swenson each initially received 3,598 votes in Mankato’s House District 11 in 1962 — a year also marked by an extremely close gubernatorial election.

News coverage from the time described Blue Earth County’s auditor placing 10 slips of paper, names evenly divided among them, in a felt hat. Five county commissioners drew one slip each.

Swenson, who caucused with conservatives, was declared the winner when three of the five slips had his name. But a recount ensued.

Johnson had better fortune in the recount. The final tally gave him a 37-vote win.

The post Heads or tails? How Minnesota cities break ties in elections appeared first on MinnPost.

Elections, Greater Minnesota, News, Politics & Policy, Top Story